What kind of output does the Bug Fix Plan Critic provide?

It generates a structured JSON report containing scores, a list of identified issues with suggestions, a summary, and a final recommendation.

What is the primary purpose of the Bug Fix Plan Critic?

It acts as an independent reviewer to audit proposed bug fix plans, ensuring they address the root cause and don't introduce new issues.

How does the skill evaluate a fix plan?

It uses a scoring rubric from 0.0 to 1.0 across five dimensions: correctness, completeness, risk assessment, test coverage, and side-effect analysis.

Does this skill automatically apply the fixes to my code?

No, this skill is designed to critique the plan itself. It provides a recommendation to 'APPROVE' or 'REVISE' before the code is actually written.

Bug Fix Plan Critic

Name: Bug Fix Plan Critic
Author: pcortes

bypcortes

0•

Security & Testing

Evaluates and scores proposed bug fix plans to ensure technical correctness, completeness, and risk mitigation.

The Bug Fix Plan Critic acts as an independent, expert reviewer for proposed code fixes within Claude Code. It systematically analyzes fix plans using a structured rubric to verify that root causes are addressed, edge cases are covered, and potential side effects are identified before any code is actually changed. By providing detailed scoring and severity-based issue reporting, it serves as a crucial quality gate that helps developers and other AI agents avoid regressive bugs and maintain high software reliability.

Key Features

01Comprehensive test coverage evaluation including regression tests

02Severity-based issue categorization (Critical, Moderate, Minor)

030 GitHub stars

04Detailed side-effect and blast radius analysis

05Structured JSON output for easy integration into dev workflows

06Multi-dimensional scoring for correctness, completeness, and risk

Use Cases

01Performing pre-commit risk assessments for complex legacy code repairs

02Ensuring robust regression testing for identified software defects

03Validating fix plans generated by other AI agents before implementation

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add pcortes/swarm-attack bug-fix-plan-critic

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

Download Skill