How does the skill handle outdated PR comments?

The skill performs a critical check by reading the current files in your branch to see if the line numbers or logic mentioned by the reviewer still exist, preventing unnecessary changes based on old code.

Does it automatically resolve GitHub discussion threads?

Yes, once the skill evaluates a comment and provides a reply or a fix, it uses the GitHub GraphQL API to automatically resolve the thread.

Does it require a PR number to function?

Not necessarily. If you don't provide a PR number, the skill will automatically attempt to find the pull request associated with your current git branch.

Will it explain why it chose not to implement a suggestion?

Absolutely. For 'Won't Fix' or 'Already Addressed' categories, the skill generates a concise, 1-2 sentence explanation for the reviewer based on the current state of the codebase.

GitHub PR Reviewer

Name: GitHub PR Reviewer
Author: richtabor

byrichtabor

•

Collaboration Tools

Automates the evaluation and resolution of GitHub pull request comments by verifying feedback against the current codebase in a single pass.

About

The GitHub PR Reviewer skill streamlines the pull request feedback loop by automatically fetching, analyzing, and addressing review comments. It performs a critical verification step by reading the actual codebase to determine if reviewer comments are still relevant, outdated, or based on a misunderstanding of the logic. Once evaluated, the skill executes a single-pass workflow that implements necessary fixes, replies to reviewers with concise reasoning, and resolves all discussion threads simultaneously, providing a comprehensive final summary of all actions taken.

Key Features

Real-time code verification to identify outdated or incorrect feedback
Single-pass execution that replies and resolves threads without manual intervention
Detailed summary generation for all addressed review conversations
Automated fetching of top-level PR comments via GitHub CLI
Intelligent categorization into Fix, Won't Fix, or Already Addressed
41 GitHub stars

Use Cases

Providing automated explanations to reviewers when their feedback is based on outdated file versions
Resolving PR threads after manual code updates to signal completion to human reviewers
Rapidly addressing large batches of feedback from automated reviewers like GitHub Copilot

About

Key Features

Real-time code verification to identify outdated or incorrect feedback
Single-pass execution that replies and resolves threads without manual intervention
Detailed summary generation for all addressed review conversations
Automated fetching of top-level PR comments via GitHub CLI
Intelligent categorization into Fix, Won't Fix, or Already Addressed
41 GitHub stars

Use Cases

Providing automated explanations to reviewers when their feedback is based on outdated file versions
Resolving PR threads after manual code updates to signal completion to human reviewers
Rapidly addressing large batches of feedback from automated reviewers like GitHub Copilot