Implementation Quality Reviewer FAQs

Name: Implementation Quality Reviewer
Author: 0pg

Question 1

Does it require the original requirement text to work?

Accepted Answer

Requirement text is optional. If provided, the skill performs a deep gap analysis (D1); if not, it skips that dimension and focuses on the structural and logical quality of the existing files.

Question 2

Can I use this skill if I don't have an IMPLEMENTS.md file yet?

Accepted Answer

Yes, the skill is flexible. It will automatically skip the planning-specific dimensions (D3) and focus its review on the quality and consistency of your CLAUDE.md file.

Question 3

What metrics does the skill use to calculate the overall score?

Accepted Answer

The score is derived from four dimensions: D1 (Requirements Coverage), D2 (Document Quality), D3 (Planning Quality), and D4 (Cross-document Consistency).

Question 4

Will this skill automatically change my files?

Accepted Answer

No. While it can propose fixes for critical issues or warnings, it will only apply changes to your documentation after you have reviewed the diff and provided explicit consent.

Question 5

How does /impl-review differ from the standard /validate command?

Accepted Answer

While /validate detects drift between code and documentation, /impl-review focuses on the internal quality, logic, and requirement coverage of the documents themselves before or during the coding process.

Implementation Quality Reviewer

Key Features

Use Cases

Implementation Quality Reviewer

Key Features

Use Cases