Does this skill perform the review itself?

No, it acts as a coordinator. It gathers all necessary project context and delegates the actual review to RepoPrompt's specialized chat or packages it for an external LLM.

What is a John Carmack-level review?

It refers to an extremely thorough and technically rigorous evaluation of code architecture, performance, and logic, named after the legendary developer known for high-standard code quality.

Is rp-cli required to use this skill?

Yes, this skill relies on rp-cli (RepoPrompt) to handle context building, file selection, and chat delegation.

Can I use this for reviewing existing Pull Requests?

Absolutely. It is specifically designed to compare your current branch changes against the main or master branch, making it perfect for PR-level reviews.

Implementation Reviewer

Name: Implementation Reviewer
Author: gmickel

bygmickel

•

356

Collaboration Tools

Conducts rigorous, deep-dive code reviews by coordinating context gathering and delegating to specialized LLM environments via RepoPrompt.

About

The flow-impl-review skill automates the complex task of preparing and executing high-level code reviews on your current branch. Acting as a coordinator rather than the primary reviewer, it uses RepoPrompt (rp-cli) to synthesize context from git diffs, commit history, architectural documentation, and project plans. This ensures that the final review—whether performed in the RepoPrompt chat or exported to an external LLM—is informed by the full scope of the project, catching architectural drift and implementation bugs that standard AI reviews might miss.

Key Features

Comprehensive branch-to-main diff analysis including commit history
Standardized workflow for John Carmack-level technical scrutiny
Automated context building using RepoPrompt (rp-cli) integration
Dual-mode execution via interactive chat or external context export
356 GitHub stars
Integration of PRDs, architecture docs, and 'beads' for issue tracking

Use Cases

Performing deep-dive technical audits before submitting a Pull Request
Verifying complex logic changes against original architecture and PRD requirements
Exporting full project context for high-quality reviews in external LLM web interfaces

About

Key Features

Comprehensive branch-to-main diff analysis including commit history
Standardized workflow for John Carmack-level technical scrutiny
Automated context building using RepoPrompt (rp-cli) integration
Dual-mode execution via interactive chat or external context export
356 GitHub stars
Integration of PRDs, architecture docs, and 'beads' for issue tracking

Use Cases

Performing deep-dive technical audits before submitting a Pull Request
Verifying complex logic changes against original architecture and PRD requirements
Exporting full project context for high-quality reviews in external LLM web interfaces