How does this skill help with stakeholder alignment?

It provides an objective, weighted criteria system that makes the rationale for a decision transparent, capturing dissenting views to ensure everyone feels heard even if they disagree.

Does this skill promote data-driven or data-informed decisions?

The framework suggests that most product decisions should be data-informed, using judgment and intuition when data is incomplete or situations are novel, rather than being purely data-driven.

When should I use a Product Decision Record (PDR)?

Use a PDR for high-stakes decisions, choosing between multiple valid technical approaches, or whenever a decision needs to be documented for future organizational learning.

What is the difference between Type 1 and Type 2 decisions?

Type 1 decisions are irreversible 'one-way doors' requiring slow, careful analysis by senior leaders. Type 2 decisions are reversible 'two-way doors' that should be made quickly and delegated widely.

Product Decision Framework

Name: Product Decision Framework
Author: flpbalada

byflpbalada

•

Productivity & Workflow

Facilitates structured product decision-making using proven frameworks to manage trade-offs, align stakeholders, and document rationale.

The Making Product Decisions skill provides a meta-framework for navigating complex product trade-offs by combining decision science principles with practical product management techniques. It guides users through framing decisions, generating diverse options, establishing weighted criteria, and evaluating choices to ensure high-quality outcomes rather than just relying on luck. By distinguishing between reversible and irreversible decisions, it helps teams optimize for speed or depth, while providing a standardized Product Decision Record (PDR) template to capture institutional knowledge, dissenting views, and success metrics directly within the development workflow.

Key Features

01Weighted decision matrices for objective option evaluation

02Standardized Product Decision Record (PDR) templates

03Type 1 vs. Type 2 decision framing for optimized speed

04Documentation of dissenting views and future review dates

059 GitHub stars

06Analysis of Data-Informed vs. Data-Driven approaches

Use Cases

01Evaluating 'Build vs. Buy' scenarios for technical infrastructure

02Prioritizing high-stakes feature roadmaps based on weighted criteria

03Aligning cross-functional stakeholders on architectural changes

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add flpbalada/thinking-toolkit making-product-decisions

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

Download Skill