Can it help with the response to reviewers?

Yes, in its final phase, it can generate a revision summary and help draft a response memo that accounts for how each piece of feedback was addressed.

What kind of research is this best for?

While generalizable, it is optimized for quantitative and qualitative sociological research as part of the social-data-analysis plugin suite.

What is the Revision Coordinator skill?

It is an orchestration tool for Claude Code that helps researchers manage complex manuscript revisions by organizing feedback and delegating tasks to specialized writing skills.

Does it work with other Claude Code skills?

Yes, it is designed to route tasks to sub-skills like lit-writeup, methods-writer, and interview-bookends to ensure domain-specific best practices are applied.

How does it handle reviewer comments?

The skill parses unstructured feedback from reviewers or editors into a structured 'Revision Map,' categorizing items by type (structural, substantive, etc.) and mapping them to specific sections.

Revision Coordinator

Name: Revision Coordinator
Author: nealcaren

bynealcaren

•

Productivity & Workflow

Orchestrates academic manuscript revisions by parsing reviewer feedback and routing tasks to specialized writing skills.

Revision Coordinator acts as a central hub for academic writing workflows, transforming messy reviewer comments or self-assessments into a structured, actionable revision plan. It systematically maps feedback to specific article sections—such as Introduction, Methods, and Theory—and invokes domain-specific skills to implement changes while maintaining global coherence. This skill is indispensable for researchers managing complex 'Revise and Resubmit' (R&R) requests, ensuring every critique is addressed while preserving the manuscript's overall narrative integrity.

Key Features

01Automated parsing of unstructured feedback into discrete, categorized action items

02Structured progress tracking via a revision-map.md for transparency and accountability

03Intelligent routing of revisions to specialized sub-skills like lit-writeup and methods-writer

04Automated generation of revision summaries and response memos for journal editors

059 GitHub stars

06Cross-section coherence checking to align introductions with findings and conclusions

Use Cases

01Synthesizing feedback from multiple co-authors into a single, cohesive revision strategy

02Managing a 'Revise and Resubmit' (R&R) request from an academic journal

03Performing a final 'promise-delivery' check to ensure findings support the introduction's claims

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add nealcaren/social-data-analysis revision-coordinator

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

Download Skill