What is the primary benefit of the two-stage review process?

It ensures that the code correctly fulfills the requirements (Stage 1) before focusing on technical refinement and maintainability (Stage 2), preventing wasted effort on high-quality code that doesn't meet the actual spec.

Does the Two-Stage Code Review check for testing and security?

Yes, the second stage includes checks for adequate test coverage, robust input validation, and proper error handling to ensure code reliability.

When is this skill typically invoked?

It is designed to be used during the development phase immediately after a task or subtask is completed to provide immediate feedback.

How does this skill prevent scope creep?

During the Specification Compliance stage, the skill explicitly checks for unauthorized features or functionality that wasn't requested in the original architecture or user stories.

Can this skill help with team coding standards?

Absolutely. It enforces standardized checks for variable naming, modular design, and function responsibility, ensuring consistency across the codebase.

Two-Stage Code Review

Name: Two-Stage Code Review
Author: pyinx

bypyinx

•

Collaboration Tools

Performs a rigorous two-phase audit to ensure code aligns with specifications and meets high maintainability standards.

About

The Two-Stage Code Review skill provides a structured framework for validating software development tasks within Claude Code. By separating the review into two distinct phases—Specification Compliance and Code Quality—it ensures that developers neither over-build nor under-build, while maintaining technical excellence. The first stage guards against scope creep and functional gaps by checking against architecture docs and user stories, while the second stage enforces best practices like modularity, single responsibility, and comprehensive test coverage, resulting in production-ready code that is both functional and sustainable.

Key Features

Comprehensive code quality checks for modularity, naming conventions, and DRY principles.
Integrated review loop for iterative improvement until all criteria are satisfied.
2 GitHub stars
Dual-phase verification process separating functional alignment from technical quality.
Security and performance auditing including input validation and error handling checks.
Scope creep prevention by auditing against architectural requirements and user stories.

Use Cases

Maintaining high code standards across a full-stack development team using AI-driven reviews.
Validating that API designs and data models match project specifications before deployment.
Automating the code audit process after completing development subtasks to ensure spec adherence.

About

Key Features

Comprehensive code quality checks for modularity, naming conventions, and DRY principles.
Integrated review loop for iterative improvement until all criteria are satisfied.
2 GitHub stars
Dual-phase verification process separating functional alignment from technical quality.
Security and performance auditing including input validation and error handling checks.
Scope creep prevention by auditing against architectural requirements and user stories.

Use Cases

Maintaining high code standards across a full-stack development team using AI-driven reviews.
Validating that API designs and data models match project specifications before deployment.
Automating the code audit process after completing development subtasks to ensure spec adherence.